Georgia Appeals Guide: How Courts Work

When there’s a legal dispute, it’s often resolved in a trial court where evidence is presented to the trial judge and jury to sway them in your favor. But if the trial outcome is unfavorable, an appeals process does exist at both the state and federal levels, where a higher court reviews the decision of a lower court (trial court) to determine if the judge’s ruling was incorrect. In today’s article, we review Georgia’s appeals system.

Types of Appeals in Georgia

The three common types of appeals in Georgia are direct appeals, interlocutory appeals, and discretionary appeals. Deciding to file an appeal involves understanding the grounds and determining the appropriate appellate court and appeal type.

• Direct Appeals: Direct appeals involve a higher court reviewing decisions from a lower court. Parties dissatisfied with a trial outcome can appeal to have the decision reversed or reconsidered. Typically filed as a matter of right initially, subsequent appeals are generally discretionary. A notice of direct appeal must usually be submitted to the trial court clerk within thirty days of the final ruling.
• Interlocutory Appeals: Interlocutory appeals, often referred to as “interrupting” appeals, can challenge pre-trial court orders. Prior to trial, if an important decision is made, an interlocutory appeal can be filed on your behalf.
• Discretionary Appeals: Unlike direct appeals, discretionary appeals are not submitted as a matter of right and involve appealing to the Georgia Supreme Court from a Georgia Court of Appeals decision. A petition to the appropriate appellate court is necessary, and approval is essential for the appeal to proceed.

Practical Differences and Timeline Impact of Appeal Types

Understanding these three categories requires looking at the practical burden placed on the appealing party. A direct appeal functions as an automatic right; as long as procedural deadlines are met, the appellate court must review the case. In contrast, preparing a discretionary application requires significantly more effort upfront because counsel must convince the court that the case warrants review before the appeal can even begin.

This distinction heavily dictates the overall case timeline. Because discretionary applications add an initial “review-and-accept” step, the court must first rule on whether to grant permission to appeal. If accepted, the formal briefing schedule begins, adding months to the process compared to direct appeals.

Interlocutory appeals arise during active litigation before a final trial judgment. For example, if a judge denies a defendant’s motion for summary judgment, the party may seek an interlocutory appeal. Getting an immediate ruling from a higher court prevents the parties from enduring an expensive trial when the case should have been resolved as a matter of law. Exploring these procedural dynamics is a core focus of our Georgia law podcast.

Considerations for Filing an Appeal

For legal disputes involving Georgia’s appeals system, seeking guidance from an experienced attorney well-versed in appellate practice is crucial.

Filing an appeal is a significant decision, mostly due to the associated length, complexity, and costs of doing so. Situations where filing an appeal might be considered include errors of law, errors of fact, and instances of abuse of discretion by the judge.

Appellate Courts in Georgia:

Georgia’s appeals system includes two courts, the Georgia Court of Appeals and the Georgia Supreme Court. The Court of Appeals is the intermediate appellate court, with authority over criminal and civil cases from courts. But it lacks jurisdiction over constitutional, homicide, and habeas corpus cases. These types of case appeals are reserved solely for the Georgia Supreme Court.

What the Briefing and Argument Process Looks Like

• Prep & Transcripts: Although you have 30 days to file a notice of appeal, acting fast is vital. Hiring counsel and ordering trial transcripts take time, and transcript delays halt the process.
• Written Briefs: Most appeals rely entirely on written arguments. The appellant files first to outline legal errors, followed by the appellee’s response brief.
• Oral Arguments: Oral arguments before a judicial panel are rare and granted solely at the court’s discretion. To learn more, explore our See You In Court Episodes Page or watch detailed breakdown videos on our YouTube Channel.

The Appeals Process in Georgia

If found guilty in a criminal proceeding or jury trial, the automatic right to appeal exists but for a limited time only, usually 30 days after sentencing. The appealing party, or appellant, seeks the appellate court’s evaluation of legal errors, including prejudicial errors and lack of substantial evidence. The process may vary based on the appeal type and case circumstances.

After the Appellate Court Rules

When the appellate court concludes its review, it issues an official decision. If the ruling is affirmed, the trial court’s decision stands as final. If the court finds significant legal error, the case may be reversed or remanded, sending the action back to the trial court with instructions for a new trial or specific corrective measures.

If a party remains dissatisfied with an adverse decision from the Georgia Court of Appeals, further review is possible through a petition for certiorari to the Supreme Court of Georgia. However, this is purely discretionary; the state Supreme Court accepts only a small percentage of petitions involving novel constitutional questions or major public policy matters. Staying informed on these legal milestones is easy when following a trusted Georgia law podcast.

Costs and Practical Realities of Appealing

Pursuing an appeal involves substantial financial and practical considerations beyond standard legal fees. Preparing the official trial record and paying court reporter fees to transcribe multi-day trials can cost thousands of dollars before a brief is even written.

Additionally, in civil disputes where money damages are awarded, filing an appeal does not automatically pause collection. To halt enforcement of the trial judgment while the appeal is pending, the losing party must often post a supersedeas bond with the court. Finally, because the time from filing a notice of appeal to receiving a final written decision routinely stretches from several months to over a year, litigants must weigh these delays against their ultimate legal objectives.

Disclaimer:

Subscribe to the See You In Court Podcast to Learn More About The Georgia Civil Justice System

For a Georgia law podcast ranging from the ins and outs of governmental liability, real-life stories from the legal world, trial courts, and Georgia’s appeals system, visit See You In Court or contact us today. Hosted by experienced attorneys, the podcast breaks down complex legal issues, making them accessible to everyday listeners. You’ll be able to listen to assessments and commentary from some of Georgia’s top legal professionals.

Please note: The information provided on this website and within our blog posts and YouTube channel is intended solely for educational and informational purposes as a public service by the Georgia Civil Justice Foundation.

Legal issues can be complex and individualized. If you are seeking legal advice, please contact a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction who can provide legal guidance that suits your particular situation.